Text Size   Decrease Font SizeIncrease Font Size

Going Dark, Going Forward - An Encryption Update

PDF Print
Privacy, Data Protection and Security
Wednesday, 27 July 2016 16:06

By: Arthur M. Freyre

The House of Representatives Homeland Security Committee issued a report on the state of the encryption debate this past month, prior to the House leaving for recess. The report called, “Going Dark, Going Forward” provides the reader with an overview concerning the encryption debate that has been going on not only here in the U.S., but in other countries. 

To understand the use and impact of encryption, consider the following facts:

  • Forty-four percent (44%) of financial services use encryption technology.
  • 30 million householders use online banking. 
  • E-commerce produces $341.7 billion of revenue to the U.S. economy.

2016 Encryption Update

Because encryption is frequently used by businesses and other people in their daily lives, the tragic events of Paris and in San Bernardino shows how encryption can also be used for wrong. Unfortunately, law enforcement has not developed the technology to break an encryption code.

The report recognizes this dilemma, as do most law enforcement officials. One approach that has been suggested comes from Professor Ron Canetti, a cryptology expert from Boston University. Professor Canetti called for law enforcement, “[to] concentrate on encryption made by bad guys. Making the everyday encryption of the general public weak isn’t going to get you what you want, [not] when it comes to coordinated terrorist attacks. There’s no silver bullet answers.”

The majority staff agreed with Professor Canetti’s perspective that there are no easy answers. The committee recommends and supports the call for a Digital Security Commission to address this dilemma. The Commission will include individuals from the various sectors that are impacted by encryption, including, but not limited to: law enforcement, e-commerce, tech, intelligence, data privacy, and civil liberties. The Commission’s focus will be to address the encryption issue and “develop policy and legislative recommendations to present to Congress.”

The committee recognizes that the encryption debate is a very complex matter and that it will take time to reach a consensus. Kudos to them for realizing this and hopefully, the committee members would heed their advice.

As former House speaker, Newt Gingrich (R-GA) and former House Intelligence Committee Jane Harman (D-CA) wrote, “The question of encryption is too central to this country’s future to answer without a real dialogue.” 


Social Media

Twitter2Facebook2LinkedIn2 YouTube Icon 

Newsletter Sign-Up

Fill out my online form.


Recent News

NBC News: New Head of US Embassy in Cuba Faces Critical Road Ahead

The newly selected Chargé d’Affaires for the US Embassy in Cuba, Mr. Philip Goldberg, officially began work at his diplomatic pos... [More]

UPDATE 20- Zakka Family Statement on Continued Unlawful Detention

Statement on the Continued Unlawful Detention of Internet Freedom Advocate/Prisoner of Conscience Nizar Zakka The following stat... [More]

©2016 PobleteTamargo LLP
Attorney Website by The Modern Firm